Because I have a job, watching every game of the World Cup isn't going to be an option this year (as it wasn't in 2006, but could have been in '02 were they not all played overnight). However, I intend to watch as much as I can, which will probably come down to one game a day plus all of the American games, at least during the group stages. For some of the games I might do a live-blog of sorts (it'll post after the game ends, but reactions will be written down live). Anyway, here's what I saw on day one.
South Africa 1-1 Mexico
I actually only was able to catch the first hour or so of the game and so missed Mexico's tying goal in the 79th. I think this is a fair result for both teams; South Africa looked like they had no business being in this tournament for most of the first half, but seemed to put things together a bit after the break, at least enough to generate a few decent chances in addition to their goal, a nice counterattack that came largely against the run of play. Mexico were probably the better side overall but never really seemed that threatening.
I didn't see France-Uruguay but I don't seem to have missed much. Eight years to the day that France were eliminated from the '02 World Cup without having scored a single goal, the two nations played another goalless draw, just as they did five days earlier in that Cup in a game that was probably the least exciting of its tournament.
More detailed posts will come in following days when I get to watch a bit more. I have to go to a wedding this weekend so you'll probably get two posts on Sunday, because I'm sure anyone is reading this.
Friday, June 11, 2010
Sunday, December 20, 2009
Marked for Death
Blame Roman Abramovich. He took over Chelsea in June 2003, and at the end of the 2003-2004 campaign the club found itself in second place in the Premiership. The following year, they won the league. Manchester City's new owners likely had their sights set on this level of improvement when they took over in the summer of 2008 and rather shockingly added Robinho, but the club finished a distant 10th, worse even than the previous season under Sven-Goran Eriksson. This year, following an enormous spending spree on players like Gareth Barry, Carlos Tevez, Kolo Toure and Emmanuel Adebayor, the club sits in 6th, but a string of draws that kept City anchored just outside of the Champions League places likely sealed Mark Hughes' fate.
Of course, everyone seems to forget that in 2002-2003, Chelsea finished fourth. It's not like Abramovich led Fulham to a title in two seasons. For all the lip service that the owners believed in Mark Hughes and believed in City as a project, in the end they were scarcely more patient than Thaksin Shinawatra, who stated before the 2007-08 season that a top-ten finish would please him and then sacked Eriksson for finishing ninth and making Europe (if only via the Fair Play League). Hughes ended up with less than a season and a half, in spite of having City just a few points shy of the top four with a game in hand and into the semifinals of the Carling Cup.
Hughes was also quite popular with many of the players, particularly the British and Irish ones, with Shay Given and Hughes' countryman Craig Bellamy evidently leading a dressing-room revolt when they got the news. At the same time, he may not have been nearly as popular with other players - not least Robinho - and it's entirely possible that the owners felt Hughes simply did not have the stature to attract the major international stars they were hoping to bring to City. Various players linked with moves had laughed them off, some saying that City did not seem a serious club at the moment. Hiring Mancini, a major international manager with massive domestic success in Serie A, was probably seen as a step in that direction; reports of attempts to lure Guus Hiddink or Jose Mourinho fall under the same category.
And they might be right about this. There is little doubt that Hughes is a capable Premiership manager, but City do not wish to be Blackburn. The only British manager who seems to draw major international stars is Alex Ferguson, and even he couldn't hang onto Cristiano Ronaldo. On the other hand, maybe it's just the weather in England; most players, given a choice, seem to prefer Spain or Italy, in spite of the millions on offer in the Premiership.
Ultimately, whether or not this was a good idea will depend on Roberto Mancini (and, to perhaps not much less an extent, on Brian Kidd). If he leads Man City to a Carling Cup title and the top four, it will be a success - maybe Mark Hughes could still have done those things, but their achievement would make most Man City fans forgiving of his ouster. If City fall to United at the next Carling hurdle and end up in the Europa League or, even worse, out of Europe once more, it will have been an unmitigated disaster. Mancini or no, what is really needed to achieve these things is a serious shoring up of the defense, especially with Joleon Lescott now on the sidelines and Kolo Toure reportedly angling to find a way back to Spain. Drumming Richard Dunne out of the club in August is looking dumber by the day.
The best-case scenario is that Mancini can guide City into the top four, and the combination of Champions League football and an international manager will prove sufficiently enticing to the top talent City's owners want to bring into the side. The worst case is that Mancini proves no more successful and City become just another revolving-door for managers and players, with the fans never knowing who's coming and going from one month to the next.
I feel bad for Mark Hughes. Much like with Eriksson, and really with Stuart Pearce before him, I don't think he was fired for reasons that were all down to him. The defense needed strengthening; how much were their struggles really down to Hughes? How much difference will Mancini make without a big January buying spree that could have happened under Hughes anyway? Ultimately, Mancini needs to prove that he can lure international stars. If he's no more successful at that, it's unlikely that this move will make any difference, aside from fracturing the dressing room. And that would really just be a shame.
Of course, everyone seems to forget that in 2002-2003, Chelsea finished fourth. It's not like Abramovich led Fulham to a title in two seasons. For all the lip service that the owners believed in Mark Hughes and believed in City as a project, in the end they were scarcely more patient than Thaksin Shinawatra, who stated before the 2007-08 season that a top-ten finish would please him and then sacked Eriksson for finishing ninth and making Europe (if only via the Fair Play League). Hughes ended up with less than a season and a half, in spite of having City just a few points shy of the top four with a game in hand and into the semifinals of the Carling Cup.
Hughes was also quite popular with many of the players, particularly the British and Irish ones, with Shay Given and Hughes' countryman Craig Bellamy evidently leading a dressing-room revolt when they got the news. At the same time, he may not have been nearly as popular with other players - not least Robinho - and it's entirely possible that the owners felt Hughes simply did not have the stature to attract the major international stars they were hoping to bring to City. Various players linked with moves had laughed them off, some saying that City did not seem a serious club at the moment. Hiring Mancini, a major international manager with massive domestic success in Serie A, was probably seen as a step in that direction; reports of attempts to lure Guus Hiddink or Jose Mourinho fall under the same category.
And they might be right about this. There is little doubt that Hughes is a capable Premiership manager, but City do not wish to be Blackburn. The only British manager who seems to draw major international stars is Alex Ferguson, and even he couldn't hang onto Cristiano Ronaldo. On the other hand, maybe it's just the weather in England; most players, given a choice, seem to prefer Spain or Italy, in spite of the millions on offer in the Premiership.
Ultimately, whether or not this was a good idea will depend on Roberto Mancini (and, to perhaps not much less an extent, on Brian Kidd). If he leads Man City to a Carling Cup title and the top four, it will be a success - maybe Mark Hughes could still have done those things, but their achievement would make most Man City fans forgiving of his ouster. If City fall to United at the next Carling hurdle and end up in the Europa League or, even worse, out of Europe once more, it will have been an unmitigated disaster. Mancini or no, what is really needed to achieve these things is a serious shoring up of the defense, especially with Joleon Lescott now on the sidelines and Kolo Toure reportedly angling to find a way back to Spain. Drumming Richard Dunne out of the club in August is looking dumber by the day.
The best-case scenario is that Mancini can guide City into the top four, and the combination of Champions League football and an international manager will prove sufficiently enticing to the top talent City's owners want to bring into the side. The worst case is that Mancini proves no more successful and City become just another revolving-door for managers and players, with the fans never knowing who's coming and going from one month to the next.
I feel bad for Mark Hughes. Much like with Eriksson, and really with Stuart Pearce before him, I don't think he was fired for reasons that were all down to him. The defense needed strengthening; how much were their struggles really down to Hughes? How much difference will Mancini make without a big January buying spree that could have happened under Hughes anyway? Ultimately, Mancini needs to prove that he can lure international stars. If he's no more successful at that, it's unlikely that this move will make any difference, aside from fracturing the dressing room. And that would really just be a shame.
Friday, December 04, 2009
The 2010 Draw, and Predictions
Hey, it's only been a year and a half since my last post. But no one reads this for my opinions on Man City and it's only now that we're really approaching 2010 hard-core. So let's do this.
Group A
South Africa
Mexico
Uruguay
France
The official FIFA world rankings only go back to 1993, which means we can only look at the last four World Cups when analyzing this next stat, but barring a miracle leap, South Africa's FIFA ranking will be the lowest ever for a host nation. Even in May 1994 the USA were ranked the #23 team in the world; in May 2002 the Japanese and South Koreans were #32 and #40 respectively. France were 18th in 1998; Germany were 19th in 2006. South Africa? As of November 2009's rankings, they're 86th, just behind Haiti and just ahead of Qatar. They're also 17th in Africa; in qualifying (which they participated in because it doubled as qualifying for the African Cup of Nations), they were eliminated in the second round, losing twice to Nigeria as well as to noted non-power Sierra Leone (currently 141st in the world). Going on results alone, they wouldn't have made this Cup, their third ever, in a million years.
That's the prize that comes with being the host nation, of course, though Mexico, Uruguay and France might argue that they were rewarded instead. Certainly France have to consider themselves one of the luckiest teams in the draw; after making it into the field by the skin of their hands (see what I did there?), Les Bleus have drawn the only weak team from the seed pot and avoided all of their European compatriots.
Mexico and Uruguay are both top 20 teams in the latest rankings, so it's not all fun and games for France, and their recent World Cup history is a bit patchy - a loss at the final hurdle of qualifying to miss the '94 Cup, winners as hosts in '98, a horrible crashout without scoring a single goal in '02, a shocking run to the final game in '06. By that standard we should be due for another poor showing, and their qualifying struggle might indicate as much. Mexico are certainly no pushovers, making the last 16 in each of the last four World Cups (though failing to advance in the knockouts each time), and I like them to get out of the group here. As for who's joining them? Well, South Africa would make history if they became the first host nation not to make it out of the group stages (even if they are almost certainly the weakest host nation in history), and they did seem to acquit themselves at the Confederations Cup. That said, I can't really justify picking them to advance; sooner or later that host streak has to end, and it likely does so here. I'll say France advance, although Uruguay wouldn't surprise me.
Group B
Argentina
Nigeria
South Korea
Greece
Were South Korea not all the way down at #52 in the latest rankings, this might look something like a Group of Death (which would have made it arguably the third Cup in a row in which Argentina ended up there). But they are, and they aren't playing at home, so this doesn't seem like their Cup. No one seems quite sure what to expect out of Nigeria or Greece either, in spite of the latter being ranked 12th. Really, even Argentina are a bit of a mystery given their slog through CONMEBOL qualifying. Aside from Argentina not advancing, little out of this group would surprise me. Nigeria are playing on their home continent, and they made the Olympic finals in 2008 (although, as we all know, not every nation takes those wholly seriously), so I could see them making it out as well.
Group C
England
United States
Algeria
Slovenia
After getting drawn into a Group of Near-Death in 2006, the Americans seem to have lucked out here. England, while #9 in the world, were the lowest ranked of the seeds aside from South Africa. Ghana and Paraguay are the only teams in the CONMEBOL/CAF pot ranked lower than Algeria, and Slovenia are #33 in the world only after a bizarre 16-spot jump following their playoff defeat of Russia. Nevertheless, out of the 13 UEFA teams in the field, they're 12th in the rankings, ahead of only Slovakia (and that by a single point). It's not that these teams are going to be pushovers, but can you imagine if this group were England-USA-Ivory Coast-Portugal instead? That probably would have been the Group of Death.
You have to like the US' chances to advance regardless, simply because this World Cup isn't in Europe. Here's a fun fact: all-time, here are the Americans' records in World Cups hosted in Europe as opposed to those hosted everywhere else:
Europe (1934, 1990, 1998, 2006): 0-1-9, -16 GD
Elsewhere (1930, 1950, 1994, 2002): 6-2-7, -4 GD
So maybe they're not a juggernaut outside of Europe, but I think we can all agree that's a pretty significant difference. Add to that a group that isn't particularly strong, and I have to like the US' chances of advancing. England should also get out of the group barring a surprise.
Group D
Germany
Australia
Serbia
Ghana
Serbia (and Montenegro, at the time) were the surprise of 2006 qualifying, but in the actual tournament they wound up in the Group of Death and failed to pick up a single point. This time things seem a little more open. Ghana and Australia were both darlings of the '06 tournament, making the knockouts, but neither is dominant; Ghana, at #37, is one of the lowest-ranked nations in the field. Germany will almost certainly make it out of this group; beyond that, any of the other three is possible, though I would install Australia as the slight favorite.
Group E
Netherlands
Denmark
Japan
Cameroon
Cameroon became the first African nation to reach the quarterfinals of a World Cup, in 1990, but they've got just one win and no knockout appearances since. They're ranked 11th in the world right now, though, and in a group of only moderate difficulty on "home" soil, expectations will be high. The same can probably be said for the Dutch, #3 in the world and one of only two or three nations with a serious claim to the "best footballing nation never to win a World Cup" mantle. The Danes sit well back at #26, one of UEFA's weaker entrants by ranking, though they were 15th in the world this summer and beat Portugal in Lisbon en route to winning their qualifying group outright. Japan, currently languishing at 43rd in the world, seem unlikely to finish anywhere other than bottom of this group. Cameroon and the Netherlands are my picks to advance.
Group F
Italy
Paraguay
New Zealand
Slovakia
The reigning champs have been handed an almost insultingly easy draw. While Paraguay are making their fourth straight appearance and reached the knockouts in both 1998 and 2002, most of their key qualifying scalps (wins over Brazil and Argentina in particular) came at home. New Zealand might be the weakest team in the field; they're ranked #77, which isn't the outright worst, but when you add to that their play in Oceania, in which most nations are ranked below #150, they don't exactly get tested much. (To be fair, they did have to win a playoff to get here, but it came against Bahrain, hardly a powerhouse.) Only two years ago the Kiwis were ranked #156 themselves. They're a nice story but will almost certainly finish last. Slovakia are dead last among the UEFA teams in FIFA's rankings; the outcome of the group will probably be determined by their game with Paraguay. I like Italy and Paraguay to advance.
Group G
Brazil
North Korea
Ivory Coast
Portugal
If there is to be a Group of Death this year, this is probably it, though the presence of North Korea (at #84, the lowest-ranked team that played their way in) sticks out like a sore thumb. We're surely going to hear all kinds of talk about their shock win over Italy in 1966, and the 3-0 lead they had on Portugal before falling 5-3, but that was 44 years ago. This North Korea will almost certainly get worked like a speedbag by their more talented opponents. Here, too, the outcome of the group will probably come down to one game: Portugal-Ivory Coast. I have high hopes for the entertainment value of that game, though unfortunately the fact that it comes first on Portugal's schedule means that their third game versus Brazil will likely not be as good as it could be. I'll take the two Portuguese-speaking nations to advance here, though Ivory Coast certainly have a shot.
Group H
Spain
Switzerland
Honduras
Chile
Perhaps the most intriguing group. Spain are the best team in the world but have a long history of failure in the World Cup, lining up with the Dutch to lay claim to the "best footballing nation never to win a World Cup" title. While they regularly make the knockouts, only once (1950) have they made it past the quarterfinals. Now they're #1 in the FIFA rankings and the defending European champions; much more will be expected. Winning this group should be no problem; it's second place that will be hotly contested. Switzerland, Honduras and Chile are all relatively unknown teams on the larger world scale, but all might qualify for the title of "feistiest team in the 2010 World Cup." Chile are 17th in the world and Switzerland are 18th; Honduras are a distant 38th but were an exciting side during CONCACAF qualifying. Anyone could come second in this group, but I give the Swiss a slight edge based on their strong showing in 2006 and group win in qualifying thanks to a sweep of Greece (in spite of a somewhat embarrassing home loss to minnows Luxembourg).
Group A
South Africa
Mexico
Uruguay
France
The official FIFA world rankings only go back to 1993, which means we can only look at the last four World Cups when analyzing this next stat, but barring a miracle leap, South Africa's FIFA ranking will be the lowest ever for a host nation. Even in May 1994 the USA were ranked the #23 team in the world; in May 2002 the Japanese and South Koreans were #32 and #40 respectively. France were 18th in 1998; Germany were 19th in 2006. South Africa? As of November 2009's rankings, they're 86th, just behind Haiti and just ahead of Qatar. They're also 17th in Africa; in qualifying (which they participated in because it doubled as qualifying for the African Cup of Nations), they were eliminated in the second round, losing twice to Nigeria as well as to noted non-power Sierra Leone (currently 141st in the world). Going on results alone, they wouldn't have made this Cup, their third ever, in a million years.
That's the prize that comes with being the host nation, of course, though Mexico, Uruguay and France might argue that they were rewarded instead. Certainly France have to consider themselves one of the luckiest teams in the draw; after making it into the field by the skin of their hands (see what I did there?), Les Bleus have drawn the only weak team from the seed pot and avoided all of their European compatriots.
Mexico and Uruguay are both top 20 teams in the latest rankings, so it's not all fun and games for France, and their recent World Cup history is a bit patchy - a loss at the final hurdle of qualifying to miss the '94 Cup, winners as hosts in '98, a horrible crashout without scoring a single goal in '02, a shocking run to the final game in '06. By that standard we should be due for another poor showing, and their qualifying struggle might indicate as much. Mexico are certainly no pushovers, making the last 16 in each of the last four World Cups (though failing to advance in the knockouts each time), and I like them to get out of the group here. As for who's joining them? Well, South Africa would make history if they became the first host nation not to make it out of the group stages (even if they are almost certainly the weakest host nation in history), and they did seem to acquit themselves at the Confederations Cup. That said, I can't really justify picking them to advance; sooner or later that host streak has to end, and it likely does so here. I'll say France advance, although Uruguay wouldn't surprise me.
Group B
Argentina
Nigeria
South Korea
Greece
Were South Korea not all the way down at #52 in the latest rankings, this might look something like a Group of Death (which would have made it arguably the third Cup in a row in which Argentina ended up there). But they are, and they aren't playing at home, so this doesn't seem like their Cup. No one seems quite sure what to expect out of Nigeria or Greece either, in spite of the latter being ranked 12th. Really, even Argentina are a bit of a mystery given their slog through CONMEBOL qualifying. Aside from Argentina not advancing, little out of this group would surprise me. Nigeria are playing on their home continent, and they made the Olympic finals in 2008 (although, as we all know, not every nation takes those wholly seriously), so I could see them making it out as well.
Group C
England
United States
Algeria
Slovenia
After getting drawn into a Group of Near-Death in 2006, the Americans seem to have lucked out here. England, while #9 in the world, were the lowest ranked of the seeds aside from South Africa. Ghana and Paraguay are the only teams in the CONMEBOL/CAF pot ranked lower than Algeria, and Slovenia are #33 in the world only after a bizarre 16-spot jump following their playoff defeat of Russia. Nevertheless, out of the 13 UEFA teams in the field, they're 12th in the rankings, ahead of only Slovakia (and that by a single point). It's not that these teams are going to be pushovers, but can you imagine if this group were England-USA-Ivory Coast-Portugal instead? That probably would have been the Group of Death.
You have to like the US' chances to advance regardless, simply because this World Cup isn't in Europe. Here's a fun fact: all-time, here are the Americans' records in World Cups hosted in Europe as opposed to those hosted everywhere else:
Europe (1934, 1990, 1998, 2006): 0-1-9, -16 GD
Elsewhere (1930, 1950, 1994, 2002): 6-2-7, -4 GD
So maybe they're not a juggernaut outside of Europe, but I think we can all agree that's a pretty significant difference. Add to that a group that isn't particularly strong, and I have to like the US' chances of advancing. England should also get out of the group barring a surprise.
Group D
Germany
Australia
Serbia
Ghana
Serbia (and Montenegro, at the time) were the surprise of 2006 qualifying, but in the actual tournament they wound up in the Group of Death and failed to pick up a single point. This time things seem a little more open. Ghana and Australia were both darlings of the '06 tournament, making the knockouts, but neither is dominant; Ghana, at #37, is one of the lowest-ranked nations in the field. Germany will almost certainly make it out of this group; beyond that, any of the other three is possible, though I would install Australia as the slight favorite.
Group E
Netherlands
Denmark
Japan
Cameroon
Cameroon became the first African nation to reach the quarterfinals of a World Cup, in 1990, but they've got just one win and no knockout appearances since. They're ranked 11th in the world right now, though, and in a group of only moderate difficulty on "home" soil, expectations will be high. The same can probably be said for the Dutch, #3 in the world and one of only two or three nations with a serious claim to the "best footballing nation never to win a World Cup" mantle. The Danes sit well back at #26, one of UEFA's weaker entrants by ranking, though they were 15th in the world this summer and beat Portugal in Lisbon en route to winning their qualifying group outright. Japan, currently languishing at 43rd in the world, seem unlikely to finish anywhere other than bottom of this group. Cameroon and the Netherlands are my picks to advance.
Group F
Italy
Paraguay
New Zealand
Slovakia
The reigning champs have been handed an almost insultingly easy draw. While Paraguay are making their fourth straight appearance and reached the knockouts in both 1998 and 2002, most of their key qualifying scalps (wins over Brazil and Argentina in particular) came at home. New Zealand might be the weakest team in the field; they're ranked #77, which isn't the outright worst, but when you add to that their play in Oceania, in which most nations are ranked below #150, they don't exactly get tested much. (To be fair, they did have to win a playoff to get here, but it came against Bahrain, hardly a powerhouse.) Only two years ago the Kiwis were ranked #156 themselves. They're a nice story but will almost certainly finish last. Slovakia are dead last among the UEFA teams in FIFA's rankings; the outcome of the group will probably be determined by their game with Paraguay. I like Italy and Paraguay to advance.
Group G
Brazil
North Korea
Ivory Coast
Portugal
If there is to be a Group of Death this year, this is probably it, though the presence of North Korea (at #84, the lowest-ranked team that played their way in) sticks out like a sore thumb. We're surely going to hear all kinds of talk about their shock win over Italy in 1966, and the 3-0 lead they had on Portugal before falling 5-3, but that was 44 years ago. This North Korea will almost certainly get worked like a speedbag by their more talented opponents. Here, too, the outcome of the group will probably come down to one game: Portugal-Ivory Coast. I have high hopes for the entertainment value of that game, though unfortunately the fact that it comes first on Portugal's schedule means that their third game versus Brazil will likely not be as good as it could be. I'll take the two Portuguese-speaking nations to advance here, though Ivory Coast certainly have a shot.
Group H
Spain
Switzerland
Honduras
Chile
Perhaps the most intriguing group. Spain are the best team in the world but have a long history of failure in the World Cup, lining up with the Dutch to lay claim to the "best footballing nation never to win a World Cup" title. While they regularly make the knockouts, only once (1950) have they made it past the quarterfinals. Now they're #1 in the FIFA rankings and the defending European champions; much more will be expected. Winning this group should be no problem; it's second place that will be hotly contested. Switzerland, Honduras and Chile are all relatively unknown teams on the larger world scale, but all might qualify for the title of "feistiest team in the 2010 World Cup." Chile are 17th in the world and Switzerland are 18th; Honduras are a distant 38th but were an exciting side during CONCACAF qualifying. Anyone could come second in this group, but I give the Swiss a slight edge based on their strong showing in 2006 and group win in qualifying thanks to a sweep of Greece (in spite of a somewhat embarrassing home loss to minnows Luxembourg).
Saturday, June 07, 2008
Hughes the man
While I was away on vacation, the Eriksson dismissal became official. Shinawatra said that the second half fall was simply too much for him to take, and while I think that's a bit reactionary - is it really the manager's fault, or was it to a large degree a lack of depth? - I guess he does have a point. Between the critical choke against Fulham and the 8-1 loss at Boro, City suffered the two worst possible ways to lose (a late collapse and a total blowout) down the end of a season in which they were in desperate need of points to stay alive in the European chase.
I still wouldn't have fired Eriksson, but you could certainly do worse as a replacement than Mark Hughes, who made Blackburn a fairly legitimate team (and one with which City routinely had trouble) in the last few years, including taking them to the UEFA Cup a couple of times, a task he's now handed with City. I'll also be interested to see what players are coming in - the rumors have Thaksin extremely interested in making Eastlands into Brazil North, but I'm not sure whether Ronaldinho is really the kind of player who'd fit in at City, having spent the last year or so looking fairly undisciplined and out of form at Barcelona. Jo, maybe more so. Something about Man City the last few years has sapped the life out of every striker they've brought in (even though the midfield has seemed talented), with the possible exception of Martin Petrov. Jo has been linked to Arsenal and AC Milan in the past, so, you know, he might actually be good. Of course, you never know what to expect from players playing in England for the first time, but at least Jo has been playing in Russia, where the weather is worse if anything.
One thing I do wonder about Hughes - his name has been mentioned as the leading favorite to replace Sir Alex Ferguson when the latter retires from United, something which could happen in the next few years or even sooner. What happens if United win the league again next year and Ferguson decides to walk away - and United approach Hughes? Four managers in four years for City? Not exactly the way to establish your club as a perennial top-six challenger.
I still wouldn't have fired Eriksson, but you could certainly do worse as a replacement than Mark Hughes, who made Blackburn a fairly legitimate team (and one with which City routinely had trouble) in the last few years, including taking them to the UEFA Cup a couple of times, a task he's now handed with City. I'll also be interested to see what players are coming in - the rumors have Thaksin extremely interested in making Eastlands into Brazil North, but I'm not sure whether Ronaldinho is really the kind of player who'd fit in at City, having spent the last year or so looking fairly undisciplined and out of form at Barcelona. Jo, maybe more so. Something about Man City the last few years has sapped the life out of every striker they've brought in (even though the midfield has seemed talented), with the possible exception of Martin Petrov. Jo has been linked to Arsenal and AC Milan in the past, so, you know, he might actually be good. Of course, you never know what to expect from players playing in England for the first time, but at least Jo has been playing in Russia, where the weather is worse if anything.
One thing I do wonder about Hughes - his name has been mentioned as the leading favorite to replace Sir Alex Ferguson when the latter retires from United, something which could happen in the next few years or even sooner. What happens if United win the league again next year and Ferguson decides to walk away - and United approach Hughes? Four managers in four years for City? Not exactly the way to establish your club as a perennial top-six challenger.
Friday, May 23, 2008
Is Sven-Goran Eriksson now trying to get fired?
The talk out of Eastlands for a good two months now (at least) has been that Sven-Goran Eriksson, after just one season in charge of Manchester City, was on the way out because of dissatisfaction from Thaksin Shinawatra - or "George Thai-nbrenner," as I have taken to nicknaming him - over the club's results in the second half of the season. However, in spite of an 8-1 drubbing at Middlesbrough on the final match day and a subsequent pair of 3-1 losses to Asian all-star teams, the sword of Damocles is still hanging by its hair above Eriksson's head. No doubt a bid to the UEFA Cup, however completely unexpected and only barely earned on actual competitive merit, has given Shinawatra some pause, and Eriksson's comments to the press have largely avoided speculation, as he talks mostly about the future of the club but in such a way that it can't really be determined from his chosen words whether he's including himself in that future. Not bad considering English isn't even close to his first language.
Here's the question, though: if you were Sven-Goran Eriksson, would you want to get fired?
The initial talk was that Eriksson would be pressured to resign. But why should he resign? He did the job he was asked to do - getting the club into the top ten in his first season - and obviously he's not going to walk away from that kind of money. If Shinawatra wants him out that badly, he's going to have to eat Sven's contract for the last two years. And in the end, it could indeed be this that stays his hand; could he really want Sven gone so badly that he would just write off millions of pounds?
But then, if you're Sven, do you want to go through two more years of this? If doing exactly what the owner asked for in his first season got Eriksson buried by rumors that he hadn't done enough and was about to be sacked, what's going to happen next year if he doesn't get City into the top six? (And with a UEFA Cup bid already in the offing this season, who's to say Thaksin's eyes don't widen to dinner plates again if City start 2008-09 in the top four just as they did 2007-08?) What about in 2009-10, when Eriksson is being asked - no pressure! - to guide City into the top four, a position only occasionally reached by clubs other than Man U, Chelsea, Liverpool and Arsenal in the history of the Premiership?
The problem, as I see it, is that in stepping in with a lot of money, Shinawatra has determined that he should be getting for his cash whatever he wants to get for it. The time frame for moving into the top four is almost embarrassingly ambitious, and in threatening to sack Eriksson so quickly, Thaksin has displayed an extremely short-sighted approach to his ownership. In various interviews with the official club podcast, Thaksin had stated on multiple occasions that the top ten was the plan for 2007-08, and appeared to acknowledge that the club's late-season struggles were due in part to injuries and a general lack of depth which, he suggested, would be remedied over the summer. Now it just seems like he was lying through his teeth. The depth issue may still be remedied, but the very act of acknowledging it tells you that Eriksson does not seem to blame for the post-New Year's dip in form. More than likely, Shinawatra just got greedy, eyeing that early-season splash and assuming that things could stay that way all season without fail.
City have dropped two 3-1 defeats to Asian all-star sides you'd think a Premier League club could have defeated, but you have to consider the sides City put out - in the second game, agains the South China Invitational XI, Eriksson started just four players who had featured regularly all year in Darius Vassell, Martin Petrov, Geovanni, and Javier Garrido. Meanwhile, five players from the City youth squad saw significant time, and the second-half struggles were in front of a fourth-string goaltender whose name I'd never even read before. This is the time at which you have to wonder whether Eriksson was using meaningless friendlies to see what he could get out of reserves and Academy players, or whether he was conspicuously starting subpar sides while right under Shinawatra's nose in the hope of forcing the chairman to swing the axe. The rumors have been swirling that Sven has already signed a provisional deal with Benfica to become their manager as soon as he is fired by City; other rumors had the Mexican national team extending him an offer to be their coach. The mere fact that one of the biggest and most successful European clubs has been so desperate to bring Eriksson in (and a fairly prominent international team as well) should suggest to Thaksin that just maybe he really does have a good manager on his hands after all. But after having done all he can to alienate Eriksson, it may just be that Shinawatra will have to give him the boot, lest the Swede maintain the recent form where both he and the players have started to seem like they'd rather be anywhere but Manchester City.
Here's the question, though: if you were Sven-Goran Eriksson, would you want to get fired?
The initial talk was that Eriksson would be pressured to resign. But why should he resign? He did the job he was asked to do - getting the club into the top ten in his first season - and obviously he's not going to walk away from that kind of money. If Shinawatra wants him out that badly, he's going to have to eat Sven's contract for the last two years. And in the end, it could indeed be this that stays his hand; could he really want Sven gone so badly that he would just write off millions of pounds?
But then, if you're Sven, do you want to go through two more years of this? If doing exactly what the owner asked for in his first season got Eriksson buried by rumors that he hadn't done enough and was about to be sacked, what's going to happen next year if he doesn't get City into the top six? (And with a UEFA Cup bid already in the offing this season, who's to say Thaksin's eyes don't widen to dinner plates again if City start 2008-09 in the top four just as they did 2007-08?) What about in 2009-10, when Eriksson is being asked - no pressure! - to guide City into the top four, a position only occasionally reached by clubs other than Man U, Chelsea, Liverpool and Arsenal in the history of the Premiership?
The problem, as I see it, is that in stepping in with a lot of money, Shinawatra has determined that he should be getting for his cash whatever he wants to get for it. The time frame for moving into the top four is almost embarrassingly ambitious, and in threatening to sack Eriksson so quickly, Thaksin has displayed an extremely short-sighted approach to his ownership. In various interviews with the official club podcast, Thaksin had stated on multiple occasions that the top ten was the plan for 2007-08, and appeared to acknowledge that the club's late-season struggles were due in part to injuries and a general lack of depth which, he suggested, would be remedied over the summer. Now it just seems like he was lying through his teeth. The depth issue may still be remedied, but the very act of acknowledging it tells you that Eriksson does not seem to blame for the post-New Year's dip in form. More than likely, Shinawatra just got greedy, eyeing that early-season splash and assuming that things could stay that way all season without fail.
City have dropped two 3-1 defeats to Asian all-star sides you'd think a Premier League club could have defeated, but you have to consider the sides City put out - in the second game, agains the South China Invitational XI, Eriksson started just four players who had featured regularly all year in Darius Vassell, Martin Petrov, Geovanni, and Javier Garrido. Meanwhile, five players from the City youth squad saw significant time, and the second-half struggles were in front of a fourth-string goaltender whose name I'd never even read before. This is the time at which you have to wonder whether Eriksson was using meaningless friendlies to see what he could get out of reserves and Academy players, or whether he was conspicuously starting subpar sides while right under Shinawatra's nose in the hope of forcing the chairman to swing the axe. The rumors have been swirling that Sven has already signed a provisional deal with Benfica to become their manager as soon as he is fired by City; other rumors had the Mexican national team extending him an offer to be their coach. The mere fact that one of the biggest and most successful European clubs has been so desperate to bring Eriksson in (and a fairly prominent international team as well) should suggest to Thaksin that just maybe he really does have a good manager on his hands after all. But after having done all he can to alienate Eriksson, it may just be that Shinawatra will have to give him the boot, lest the Swede maintain the recent form where both he and the players have started to seem like they'd rather be anywhere but Manchester City.
Monday, May 05, 2008
Sven... and now?
Given the recent history of Manchester City, a guaranteed top-ten finish with three games to go - to say nothing of a derby double over United - would have endeared any manager to the City faithful. But Sven-Goran Eriksson also brought an eye for talent and a stylistic flair not seen at City for some time, winning him legions of fans - most crucially club owner Thaksin Shinawatra. Thaksin declared his admiration for Sven in an interview with the club's official podcast in late October, saying City were "lucky" to have him as manager, and in another interview in mid-February told of his affinity for Eriksson's coaching style. There were, at the time, virtually no hints of the soap opera to come - in which rumors poured out of Eastlands that Sven was going to be asked to resign at season's end, and that he would likely be fired outright if he didn't.
To be sure, City limped down the stretch after spending much of the year in the European places. And Sven's biggest-money buy of the summer, Rolando Bianchi, was back in Italy within six months. But the majority of Sven's buys did catch on, and the squad was bitten by the injury bug a few times, most critically losing defensive superstar Micah Richards for much of the season's second half. Above all, it was a five-place improvement over City's 14th-place finish in 2006-07, and those Blues scored an embarrassing 29 goals all season, to this year's 44 - still not a lot in 37 games so far, but a marked improvement. City will also finish with more wins than losses this year no matter what happens in match #38 against Boro this Sunday at the Riverside, and with 15 wins so far they've already won as many contests this year as in any since returning to the top flight in 2002-03, and a win against Boro would be the most. By all normal City standards, it's been a pretty successful year, and one that lived up to Thaksin Shinawatra's stated preseason goal of a top ten finish.
But despite living up to that goal, the rumors have been persistent that Eriksson is on the way out. The manager himself has mostly refused to address the rumors directly, but as he repeatedly thanks the fans for the support they have shown him, he sounds like a man satisfied that his days are numbered but not entirely sure why. In his interview on the most recent club podcast, Sven sounded weary, tired of addressing the rumors but unable to deny them. His agent has stated that Sven does not plan to resign but at the same time that he does not expect Sven to be with the club next season; the players have united behind Sven, to the extent of apparently planning to boycott a preseason Thailand tour (which Sven reportedly talked them out of doing), but it's not clear if this is having any effect. One thing is for sure - there's only one man whose opinion counts, and he certainly seems to have his mind made up.
The question is: why?
1. City's sliding finish - a 5-4-8 record since the New Year (after a 10-6-4 fall) - led Shinawatra to believe that Sven couldn't effectively manage a team for a full season.
If he really believes this, he should just sell the team right now, because it suggests to me that he knows nothing about football. True, City were maddeningly inconsistent in 2008 - they beat Man U (at Old Trafford!), Spurs and Pompey, but they lost a heartbreaker-cum-choke job to Fulham in the final home game, lost to then-rivals Everton twice in the span of six weeks, lost 3-1 and 2-0 to relegation strugglers Birmingham and Reading, and slogged through frustrating draws with Wigan, Bolton, West Ham, and Derby, only the worst team in Premiership history. But while football is a results-oriented business, you have to consider that Micah Richards missed the last two months, and furthermore that several regulars in the City side have been playing their first season in the Premiership, possibly the toughest league in the world. Other teams may have made adjustments to players like Elano, Geovanni and Martin Petrov; some of them may have tired out a bit over the rough schedule in a way they might not do in future years with a season or more under their belt.
Try looking at it this way - suppose City started 5-4-8, then finished with a 10-6-4 run down the stretch. Eriksson would be lauded for having gotten the team to play together effectively, and it's highly unlikely that there'd be any calls for his head from the top. The inability to build momentum was a problem, but there are any number of possible reasons for it, many of which have nothing to do with Sven.
2. Shinawatra found a bigger manager on offer.
Who else is out there? Big Phil Scolari is the only name I've heard seriously mentioned who seems like a theoretical "upgrade," except that Scolari has said in the past that he'd never want to live in England, and he doesn't have the European club experience that Sven does. Mourinho isn't coming to City, I don't care how much money you throw at him, and furthermore Chelsea's Champions League breakthrough under Grant proves that Mourinho isn't the King Midas everyone thought anyway.
3. Shinawatra feels jealous of the loyalty to Sven exhibited by the fans.
This would just be ridiculous and beyond petty, so I hope it's not true. But in that same mid-February interview, Thaksin said "I want [the fans] to love me." And they may, but you know who they love more right now? Sven-Goran Eriksson. You fire Sven and you are absolutely King Asshole. But if anything, it's possible that the fan outcry has only hardened Thaksin's resolve - sure, he's going to be unpopular at first if he fires Sven, but ultimately, he's the one with the money. And if his next coach does take City to silverware, Thaksin's going to be able to take a lot of the credit (although the coach is going to get a lot of it too). And then the fans definitely will love him. But that's quite a calculated risk, and again, being jealous of Sven would just be childish.
Are there any other possibilities? I just don't get it. Everyone wants Sven to stay. He's under contract. There's only one game left; after that, it's in Thaksin's hands. If he cares about this team and not his own ego, at all, he'll make the right choice. But I think we're all pretty afraid he just doesn't have that in him.
To be sure, City limped down the stretch after spending much of the year in the European places. And Sven's biggest-money buy of the summer, Rolando Bianchi, was back in Italy within six months. But the majority of Sven's buys did catch on, and the squad was bitten by the injury bug a few times, most critically losing defensive superstar Micah Richards for much of the season's second half. Above all, it was a five-place improvement over City's 14th-place finish in 2006-07, and those Blues scored an embarrassing 29 goals all season, to this year's 44 - still not a lot in 37 games so far, but a marked improvement. City will also finish with more wins than losses this year no matter what happens in match #38 against Boro this Sunday at the Riverside, and with 15 wins so far they've already won as many contests this year as in any since returning to the top flight in 2002-03, and a win against Boro would be the most. By all normal City standards, it's been a pretty successful year, and one that lived up to Thaksin Shinawatra's stated preseason goal of a top ten finish.
But despite living up to that goal, the rumors have been persistent that Eriksson is on the way out. The manager himself has mostly refused to address the rumors directly, but as he repeatedly thanks the fans for the support they have shown him, he sounds like a man satisfied that his days are numbered but not entirely sure why. In his interview on the most recent club podcast, Sven sounded weary, tired of addressing the rumors but unable to deny them. His agent has stated that Sven does not plan to resign but at the same time that he does not expect Sven to be with the club next season; the players have united behind Sven, to the extent of apparently planning to boycott a preseason Thailand tour (which Sven reportedly talked them out of doing), but it's not clear if this is having any effect. One thing is for sure - there's only one man whose opinion counts, and he certainly seems to have his mind made up.
The question is: why?
1. City's sliding finish - a 5-4-8 record since the New Year (after a 10-6-4 fall) - led Shinawatra to believe that Sven couldn't effectively manage a team for a full season.
If he really believes this, he should just sell the team right now, because it suggests to me that he knows nothing about football. True, City were maddeningly inconsistent in 2008 - they beat Man U (at Old Trafford!), Spurs and Pompey, but they lost a heartbreaker-cum-choke job to Fulham in the final home game, lost to then-rivals Everton twice in the span of six weeks, lost 3-1 and 2-0 to relegation strugglers Birmingham and Reading, and slogged through frustrating draws with Wigan, Bolton, West Ham, and Derby, only the worst team in Premiership history. But while football is a results-oriented business, you have to consider that Micah Richards missed the last two months, and furthermore that several regulars in the City side have been playing their first season in the Premiership, possibly the toughest league in the world. Other teams may have made adjustments to players like Elano, Geovanni and Martin Petrov; some of them may have tired out a bit over the rough schedule in a way they might not do in future years with a season or more under their belt.
Try looking at it this way - suppose City started 5-4-8, then finished with a 10-6-4 run down the stretch. Eriksson would be lauded for having gotten the team to play together effectively, and it's highly unlikely that there'd be any calls for his head from the top. The inability to build momentum was a problem, but there are any number of possible reasons for it, many of which have nothing to do with Sven.
2. Shinawatra found a bigger manager on offer.
Who else is out there? Big Phil Scolari is the only name I've heard seriously mentioned who seems like a theoretical "upgrade," except that Scolari has said in the past that he'd never want to live in England, and he doesn't have the European club experience that Sven does. Mourinho isn't coming to City, I don't care how much money you throw at him, and furthermore Chelsea's Champions League breakthrough under Grant proves that Mourinho isn't the King Midas everyone thought anyway.
3. Shinawatra feels jealous of the loyalty to Sven exhibited by the fans.
This would just be ridiculous and beyond petty, so I hope it's not true. But in that same mid-February interview, Thaksin said "I want [the fans] to love me." And they may, but you know who they love more right now? Sven-Goran Eriksson. You fire Sven and you are absolutely King Asshole. But if anything, it's possible that the fan outcry has only hardened Thaksin's resolve - sure, he's going to be unpopular at first if he fires Sven, but ultimately, he's the one with the money. And if his next coach does take City to silverware, Thaksin's going to be able to take a lot of the credit (although the coach is going to get a lot of it too). And then the fans definitely will love him. But that's quite a calculated risk, and again, being jealous of Sven would just be childish.
Are there any other possibilities? I just don't get it. Everyone wants Sven to stay. He's under contract. There's only one game left; after that, it's in Thaksin's hands. If he cares about this team and not his own ego, at all, he'll make the right choice. But I think we're all pretty afraid he just doesn't have that in him.
Tuesday, August 21, 2007
Blue moon, you saw me standing alone in first place
It's way, way too early to get too excited - especially with the wins coming over a newly-promoted Derby, a nearly-relegated West Ham, and a United team that was merely missing its two best players. But nine points from three games - and no goals allowed yet - is a pretty exciting start to the season, especially leaving City as it does alone in first, two points clear of Chelsea. The new players seem to be fitting together pretty well, and Schmeichel is performing capably, though of course the real star is Micah Richards, as anyone could have predicted.
The next three games will tell the story: at Arsenal, at Bristol City in the Carling Cup, at Blackburn. City rarely beat Arsenal, never beat Blackburn, and have struggled in the Carling recently, bowing out to much lesser opposition than Bristol, a Championship team, in each of the last two seasons. If City can get through September with no more than one loss - and the post-Blackburn games are Aston Villa, at Fulham, and Newcastle, so the possibility exists - then I may start getting very excited. For now it's just nice to see a fast start - of course, 2005/06 started similarly - D-W-W-W-D, the last draw an inspiring hold at Old Trafford - and then collapsed following the debacle at Doncaster. Fingers crossed that Sven doesn't repeat the same freefall to 15th in the table that that team had. (I'm guessing not, if only because of the available funds that didn't exist in 2005.)
The next three games will tell the story: at Arsenal, at Bristol City in the Carling Cup, at Blackburn. City rarely beat Arsenal, never beat Blackburn, and have struggled in the Carling recently, bowing out to much lesser opposition than Bristol, a Championship team, in each of the last two seasons. If City can get through September with no more than one loss - and the post-Blackburn games are Aston Villa, at Fulham, and Newcastle, so the possibility exists - then I may start getting very excited. For now it's just nice to see a fast start - of course, 2005/06 started similarly - D-W-W-W-D, the last draw an inspiring hold at Old Trafford - and then collapsed following the debacle at Doncaster. Fingers crossed that Sven doesn't repeat the same freefall to 15th in the table that that team had. (I'm guessing not, if only because of the available funds that didn't exist in 2005.)
Monday, August 13, 2007
A whole new ball game
West Ham 0-2 Man City
I didn't see the game and I haven't gotten to see the highlights either, on account of the MCFCTV.com site being down for a month while it updates something or other. I did read the recap, though, the prevailing theme of which appears to be this:
"Man City looked pretty good for a team that has only just come together, but it might just have been that West Ham were terrible."
Looking at the box score was strange; it's almost like I pull for a totally different club now. Just five starters on Saturday saw any time for City last year - Dunne, Johnson, Hamann, Ireland, and Richards - and only two more on the bench (including reserve keeper Joe Hart, who got fully one start last year). Both goals were scored by new boys.
I'm still not sure what to make of it. It's one thing to have your club sign a couple new players, but we're talking a very significant overhaul, and the removal or displacement of a lot of names I knew - Vassell and Samaras, for instance, or recent departures like Sylvain Distin - has made it almost difficult to recognize the club as City. (The irony of a fairly recent fan saying this is palpable, I'm sure, but I feel it nonetheless.) It's kind of stupid, of course, because last year's side was almost unendingly pathetic, scoring just ten goals at home and relying on its defense to stay out of the Championship. The year before that, while it started promising, finished no better. So surely it's not that I'm nostalgic. Maybe I'm just baffled at seeing a team I like actually go for it - it's almost like the Cubs this year, though they're easier to recognize because I already knew who Alfonso Soriano and Ted Lilly were, and also because the turnover was not nearly as thorough. I'll watch as many games this year as I reasonably can, and the highlights when available, and get to know this new side, and hopefully things will progress towards Europe over the next couple seasons as Shinawatra's goal is stated. But for now... it's still going to take some getting used to.
I didn't see the game and I haven't gotten to see the highlights either, on account of the MCFCTV.com site being down for a month while it updates something or other. I did read the recap, though, the prevailing theme of which appears to be this:
"Man City looked pretty good for a team that has only just come together, but it might just have been that West Ham were terrible."
Looking at the box score was strange; it's almost like I pull for a totally different club now. Just five starters on Saturday saw any time for City last year - Dunne, Johnson, Hamann, Ireland, and Richards - and only two more on the bench (including reserve keeper Joe Hart, who got fully one start last year). Both goals were scored by new boys.
I'm still not sure what to make of it. It's one thing to have your club sign a couple new players, but we're talking a very significant overhaul, and the removal or displacement of a lot of names I knew - Vassell and Samaras, for instance, or recent departures like Sylvain Distin - has made it almost difficult to recognize the club as City. (The irony of a fairly recent fan saying this is palpable, I'm sure, but I feel it nonetheless.) It's kind of stupid, of course, because last year's side was almost unendingly pathetic, scoring just ten goals at home and relying on its defense to stay out of the Championship. The year before that, while it started promising, finished no better. So surely it's not that I'm nostalgic. Maybe I'm just baffled at seeing a team I like actually go for it - it's almost like the Cubs this year, though they're easier to recognize because I already knew who Alfonso Soriano and Ted Lilly were, and also because the turnover was not nearly as thorough. I'll watch as many games this year as I reasonably can, and the highlights when available, and get to know this new side, and hopefully things will progress towards Europe over the next couple seasons as Shinawatra's goal is stated. But for now... it's still going to take some getting used to.
Sunday, July 22, 2007
It's back
Due to Man City's impossibly lackluster finish to the 2006-2007 campaign, I pretty much lost interest in posting about soccer for a while, but with the 2007-2008 season just a couple weeks from beginning, this is as good a time as any to get back into the swing of things.
I liked Stuart Pearce, so it was tough to see him go, but after two successive finishes in the bottom half of the table, and ten home goals this past year (a record low), I don't see how anyone could have been surprised. I don't know that it was all Pearce's fault - he wasn't given much money to work with, and every striker he brought in was just too inconsistent, with Samaras and Vassell having difficulty displaying their class on a match-to-match basis and Corradi struggling mightily in his first English season.
Barton was the best player on the team - at least among those who don't play on the back line (Micah Richards) - so it was a shame to see him go. But then again, it really, really wasn't. You just can't keep guys like that around. I'm not ashamed to admit that I read about his injury today and had a bit of schadenfreude about it. Couldn't have happened to a nicer guy, right?
Opinion is hugely split on the whole Shinawatra/Eriksson thing. I'm not so far terribly concerned about the owner - the charges against him have been levied by the coup that overthrew him, which doesn't exactly seem the most reputable source ever - but of course I think everyone is given a bit of pause by Eriksson, considering how his time with England ended. The optimists point to his strong club record; the pessimists point to England and the fact that his club successes mostly came in Italy. Of course, it's hard to say how much of England was Sven's fault; it seemed like he delegated a lot of the job to McLaren, which is another issue entirely, but certainly under McLaren's full-time stewardship England haven't done much so far (albeit with few chances to). You could also argue that the failure of the team to win came in part from the difficulty in assembling so many stars - I don't think even Brazil and Argentina had their sides stocked with so many world-famous players. When you have a team on which almost no one is used to being a role player - even the guys playing what are normally role-player positions - it may be hard to adjust, especially when clubs are complaining more than ever about players putting time in for their national teams. Eriksson didn't seem great about second-half adjustments, true, but look - England can't win the World Cup every year. This generation is talented, but their failure to win cannot be laid entirely at Eriksson's feet. And the fake sheik scandal notwithstanding, I think the charges that he somehow charmed Shinawatra into giving him the job are probably more than a bit overblown. Eriksson's a big name, like it or not; Shinawatra wanted to make a splash, and who else was out there?
Whether Rolando Bianchi is the striking savior of this club, I don't know; England is not Italy. It's not Sweden, either, where Bianchi has impressed with three goals in two games on City's preseason tour. But having another Italian around seems to have perked up Corradi, and that's a start. Man City have a long and sordid history of playing down to the level of their opponents, but in three preseason games so far against generally lesser opposition, they have three fairly comfortable wins. I'd call that progress.
Bring on West Ham.
I liked Stuart Pearce, so it was tough to see him go, but after two successive finishes in the bottom half of the table, and ten home goals this past year (a record low), I don't see how anyone could have been surprised. I don't know that it was all Pearce's fault - he wasn't given much money to work with, and every striker he brought in was just too inconsistent, with Samaras and Vassell having difficulty displaying their class on a match-to-match basis and Corradi struggling mightily in his first English season.
Barton was the best player on the team - at least among those who don't play on the back line (Micah Richards) - so it was a shame to see him go. But then again, it really, really wasn't. You just can't keep guys like that around. I'm not ashamed to admit that I read about his injury today and had a bit of schadenfreude about it. Couldn't have happened to a nicer guy, right?
Opinion is hugely split on the whole Shinawatra/Eriksson thing. I'm not so far terribly concerned about the owner - the charges against him have been levied by the coup that overthrew him, which doesn't exactly seem the most reputable source ever - but of course I think everyone is given a bit of pause by Eriksson, considering how his time with England ended. The optimists point to his strong club record; the pessimists point to England and the fact that his club successes mostly came in Italy. Of course, it's hard to say how much of England was Sven's fault; it seemed like he delegated a lot of the job to McLaren, which is another issue entirely, but certainly under McLaren's full-time stewardship England haven't done much so far (albeit with few chances to). You could also argue that the failure of the team to win came in part from the difficulty in assembling so many stars - I don't think even Brazil and Argentina had their sides stocked with so many world-famous players. When you have a team on which almost no one is used to being a role player - even the guys playing what are normally role-player positions - it may be hard to adjust, especially when clubs are complaining more than ever about players putting time in for their national teams. Eriksson didn't seem great about second-half adjustments, true, but look - England can't win the World Cup every year. This generation is talented, but their failure to win cannot be laid entirely at Eriksson's feet. And the fake sheik scandal notwithstanding, I think the charges that he somehow charmed Shinawatra into giving him the job are probably more than a bit overblown. Eriksson's a big name, like it or not; Shinawatra wanted to make a splash, and who else was out there?
Whether Rolando Bianchi is the striking savior of this club, I don't know; England is not Italy. It's not Sweden, either, where Bianchi has impressed with three goals in two games on City's preseason tour. But having another Italian around seems to have perked up Corradi, and that's a start. Man City have a long and sordid history of playing down to the level of their opponents, but in three preseason games so far against generally lesser opposition, they have three fairly comfortable wins. I'd call that progress.
Bring on West Ham.
Saturday, March 10, 2007
A tale of two Citys
For the second year in a row, Manchester City has been doing something rather odd - progressing to the quarterfinal round of the FA Cup (last year's appearance their first in something like two decades) while absolutely tanking in the league. The EPL season hasn't been kind to City - they've crawled no higher than ninth, currently sit just six points clear of the relegation zone, and have lost the ability even to win games at home. Since the conclusion of their surprising post-Christmas three-game winning streak, which concluded with a 2-1 win over Everton on New Year's Day, City are 0-1-4 in the league and have scored just a single goal. In the same period they're 3-1-0 in FA Cup games, although it probably bears mentioning that all three games have come against Championship opposition. City's opponent tomorrow is Blackburn, a club that City have already lost to twice this year by a combined 7-2 scoreline. In fact, boding particularly well for this tie, City last beat Blackburn on August 25, 2003, long enough ago that the winning goal was scored by Nicolas Anelka, who hasn't donned the City shirt since I started following the club, but whose goalscoring prowess certainly appears sorely missed.
With just ten games left in the season and staying up no longer the certainty it once was, perhaps it would be best if City lost to Blackburn on Sunday, which history seems to dictate they will anyway. Inability to finish has been the thorn in City's side all season, and putting all their eggs in Mido's basket only to see Spurs hold onto him at the eleventh hour of the transfer window means that the only candidate to save the season, aside from someone like Vassell or Samaras going on a seemingly unlikely tear, is Emile Mpenza, a Belgian striker whose highest all-competitions scoring total in the past six seasons is six goals in 2002-03. You will forgive my skepticism.
The point is that the FA Cup may well be a distraction. City's fortunes during last year's FA Cup run were decidedly better - four wins and five losses in nine games may not be anything to write home about, but it's certainly better than a draw and four losses in five. It's a bit suspicious on the heels of a three-game win streak. Maybe all the time off in February contributed to the sluggishness in the Wigan loss, but how do you explain 3-0 to Blackburn? (Other than the obvious fact that City can't beat Blackburn.)
There are some big games coming up. City still must host Chelsea, United and Liverpool, and there is probably no game in the remaining ten more important than April 6 when Charlton come to Eastlands. If City are still holding on by only a couple wins at that point, points will be absolutely paramount (as though they weren't already). But who's going to score? Joey Barton leads the team with five league goals but hasn't scored in the Premiership since December 17. Samaras has four goals but they've come in just two games. Vassell has found the net in the Cup, but not since November - and just once total - in the league.
It's dire. City seem to look worse with every league game, and as they've plummeted to 17th it's brought relegation worries to the front of my mind. One of the many reasons I chose to follow City was I didn't think they had much danger of being relegated, since they were a Robbie Fowler penalty miss out of Europe in 2005 when I picked them up. In 2006 they started hot and then faded to 16th; this year has been even worse. They're just 2-1-1 so far against the three teams currently occupying the relegation zone; if that number doesn't improve to 4-1-1 between now and the end of the year, things could get a lot worse.
So do I want City to advance in the FA Cup? Well, of course. It would be nice to see them exorcise the Blackburn demons, for one thing. But if they can't figure it out in the league, would it even matter? Has a Premiership team ever won the FA Cup and been relegated in the same year? I'm confident that City have talent so I don't know why it struggles so much to show itself - but if there was ever a time where they really, really needed to do that, it's now.
With just ten games left in the season and staying up no longer the certainty it once was, perhaps it would be best if City lost to Blackburn on Sunday, which history seems to dictate they will anyway. Inability to finish has been the thorn in City's side all season, and putting all their eggs in Mido's basket only to see Spurs hold onto him at the eleventh hour of the transfer window means that the only candidate to save the season, aside from someone like Vassell or Samaras going on a seemingly unlikely tear, is Emile Mpenza, a Belgian striker whose highest all-competitions scoring total in the past six seasons is six goals in 2002-03. You will forgive my skepticism.
The point is that the FA Cup may well be a distraction. City's fortunes during last year's FA Cup run were decidedly better - four wins and five losses in nine games may not be anything to write home about, but it's certainly better than a draw and four losses in five. It's a bit suspicious on the heels of a three-game win streak. Maybe all the time off in February contributed to the sluggishness in the Wigan loss, but how do you explain 3-0 to Blackburn? (Other than the obvious fact that City can't beat Blackburn.)
There are some big games coming up. City still must host Chelsea, United and Liverpool, and there is probably no game in the remaining ten more important than April 6 when Charlton come to Eastlands. If City are still holding on by only a couple wins at that point, points will be absolutely paramount (as though they weren't already). But who's going to score? Joey Barton leads the team with five league goals but hasn't scored in the Premiership since December 17. Samaras has four goals but they've come in just two games. Vassell has found the net in the Cup, but not since November - and just once total - in the league.
It's dire. City seem to look worse with every league game, and as they've plummeted to 17th it's brought relegation worries to the front of my mind. One of the many reasons I chose to follow City was I didn't think they had much danger of being relegated, since they were a Robbie Fowler penalty miss out of Europe in 2005 when I picked them up. In 2006 they started hot and then faded to 16th; this year has been even worse. They're just 2-1-1 so far against the three teams currently occupying the relegation zone; if that number doesn't improve to 4-1-1 between now and the end of the year, things could get a lot worse.
So do I want City to advance in the FA Cup? Well, of course. It would be nice to see them exorcise the Blackburn demons, for one thing. But if they can't figure it out in the league, would it even matter? Has a Premiership team ever won the FA Cup and been relegated in the same year? I'm confident that City have talent so I don't know why it struggles so much to show itself - but if there was ever a time where they really, really needed to do that, it's now.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)